• 0 Posts
  • 270 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 14th, 2023

help-circle
  • The seal looks like this:

    Code completion is probably a gray area.

    Those models generally have much smaller context windows, so the energy concern isn’t quite as extreme.

    You could also reasonably make a claim that the model is legally in the clear as far as licensing, if the training data was entirely open source (non-attribution, non-share-alike, and commercial-allowed) licensed code. (A big “if”)

    All of that to say: I don’t think I would label code-completion-using anti-AI devs as hypocrites. I think the general sentiment is less “what the technology does” and more “who it does it to”. Code completion, for the most part, isn’t deskilling labor, or turning experts into chatbot-wrangling accountability sinks.

    Like, I don’t think the Luddites would’ve had a problem with an artisan using a knitting frame in their own home. They were too busy fighting against factories locking children inside for 18-hour shifts, getting maimed by the machines or dying trapped in a fire. It was never the technology itself, but the social order that was imposed through the technology.











  • only a tool

    “The essence of technology is by no means anything technological”

    Every tool contains within it a philosophy — a particular way of seeing the world.

    But especially digital technologies… they give the developer the ability to embed their values into the tools. Like, is DoorDash just a tool?




  • Not crypto. Just digital. So, centralized, subject to anti-fraud regulation, reversible transactions, etc.

    Not loaned out. Explicitly marked as not-loanable. Which would be foolish in today’s market, because you’re losing out on a dividend. Except… the bank actually keeps most of the benefit from your deposit being loanable normally. This way, you get the benefit instead.

    Basically, it allows depositors to compete against the banks. So they can’t take you for granted, because you actually have alternative.