Please don’t take this meme too seriously, I want both platforms to succeed.
NodeBB getting left out despite having more users than both:
We all love you too NodeBB!
What are some NodeBB servers to check out?
Most of the instances I know about are focused on a particular thing, mostly software, and I’m not aware of a general purpose NodeBB instance.
cc @[email protected] any recommendations?
Mbin has <1k users combined across 10 instances that allow sign-ups (and adding Kbin to it helps not at all with only one instance remaining, in Poland)
PieFed.social alone already has nearly 1k active users, and then there are several tens of instances (surely more of them allow sign-ups than it indicates though, like PieFed.zip)
Plus the user base of PieFed has quadrupled in the last few months, rather than stagnating and actually decreasing in the same time period.
So this gun fight is already over, pardner 🤠
Mbin has <1k users combined across 10 instances that allow sign-ups (and adding Kbin to it helps not at all with only one instance remaining, in Poland)
FediDB has them at 21 servers with 1.2K MAU.
tardigram.com does not show up in my link, but does in yours. Perhaps Fediverse Explorer is only showing sites that have an English option, whereas FediDB includes other languages by default?
No, Fediverse Explorer is pulling the info from Nodeinfo which doesn’t expose language settings.
These kinds of sites just suffer from an inherent problem of never being able to have the full network. Neither has https://bookwyr.me/ in the Piefed lists despite existing.
I don’t know what the one on the left is
That’s Mbin.
mbin/kbin (they are nearly as old as lemmy)
It’s not threadiverse anymore?
confusion with Facebook’s “Threads” platform cooled that one significantly
Some people don’t like that term anymore.
Oh got damnit, did Carl forget to send out the memo again‽
Why did you kill this person Carl?
I was told there’d be cake.
(also @[email protected])
I did a poll + discussion at https://discuss.online/post/19430152 and the consensus was that Threadiverse predated Threads plus all the more so now that it died people refused to back down from it, plus liked it more than Forumverse or other terms. I have no skin in this game but I wish we’d just pick one, whatever it may be:-|.
Both are good but PieFed has currently more hype. I am seeing more and more PieFed domains (and users of course). Also there is now a variety of apps that supports PieFed.
Though if Mbin wants to gain more traction they should further develop the [email protected] app on iOS 😉
In terms of zeitgeist I think Piefed has won by far. I hardly see people suggest mbin as an alternative to Lemmy anymore. I’m pretty happy with mbin though! There are dozens of us!
Mbin in compact mode looks the most like old reddit compact. That’s what keeps me on Fedia.io. I can’t get either Lemmy or Piefed to look quite as clean and compact as mbin.
that’s what made me stick with Mbin as well
Takes a lot of humility to admit your favourite platform may not be the winner in popularity or ideals.
We can all still hang out across them all, so IMO popularity of a single platform doesn’t really matter that much. If they were all separately contained and couldn’t share content with each other like X to Reddit or Facebook, etc, that would make a bigger difference cuz people would want to go where the rest of the people are.
